Sublunary Updates (![[info]](http://l-stat.livejournal.com/img/userinfo.gif){kind=small} subbyupdates) wrote,@ 2006-02-11 05:20:00 |
|
opposing opinions
Now, it's come to my attention that Sarah has posted a piece in her journal on one of her art sites requesting opinions on my request of her. Several people IMd me to mention that it wasn't reaching a lot of Sublunary fans where it was posted and asked me to post it here. She posted the following:
"I have stopped drawing for Sublunary since it's author does not wish to work with an artist and because I do not have the time for it right now.
Reena has asked me to not upload anything Sublunary related. Which I have deemed fair, if not a little strict.
However, she has also asked me to not upload any art of MY characters in their non Subby personas. Might I remind you all that Eekie, Cyan, Robyn, Cantor, FS ex. ALL exsisted long before Sublunary was concieved.
So, as I think she is unfair in asking this and she think she has every right, since seeing A picture of Eekie or Robyn would be too distracting... what do you think? "
Poll suggestions were:
"She has no right.
She has the right.
I don't know what to believe."
As my side has already been explained in the previous post, I'd like to post her side here, where Subby fans will actually have an oppourtunity to comment on it.
I will just say that I disagree entirely with the first half of the first sentence. I admit I do not want to work with another artist, but I never said I didn't want to work with her. I would like us to be on even ground if we ever continue the comic, as a personal relationship (whether it be friends or more) is more important than a comic. Also, I do not think I have 'every right' to keep her from uploading her characters, I simply asked. My side is explained in full in the previous post, as was the statement that I would work around this since she disagreed to it and didn't offer suggestions.
So here it is for Sublunary fans to have an opinion on as she wished, with both sides of the story. I'm not trying to invite drama, I'm trying to help her get a view from the fan perspective. As I already stated, I would work around her disagreement with my suggestion so as far as I'm concerned this is pretty moot, but she wants opinions. As always, please be civil in the comments, this isn't a flame war nor should it be. Simply state your opinion for her and if need be, your reasons why.
Now, it's come to my attention that Sarah has posted a piece in her journal on one of her art sites requesting opinions on my request of her. Several people IMd me to mention that it wasn't reaching a lot of Sublunary fans where it was posted and asked me to post it here. She posted the following:
"I have stopped drawing for Sublunary since it's author does not wish to work with an artist and because I do not have the time for it right now.
Reena has asked me to not upload anything Sublunary related. Which I have deemed fair, if not a little strict.
However, she has also asked me to not upload any art of MY characters in their non Subby personas. Might I remind you all that Eekie, Cyan, Robyn, Cantor, FS ex. ALL exsisted long before Sublunary was concieved.
So, as I think she is unfair in asking this and she think she has every right, since seeing A picture of Eekie or Robyn would be too distracting... what do you think? "
Poll suggestions were:
"She has no right.
She has the right.
I don't know what to believe."
As my side has already been explained in the previous post, I'd like to post her side here, where Subby fans will actually have an oppourtunity to comment on it.
I will just say that I disagree entirely with the first half of the first sentence. I admit I do not want to work with another artist, but I never said I didn't want to work with her. I would like us to be on even ground if we ever continue the comic, as a personal relationship (whether it be friends or more) is more important than a comic. Also, I do not think I have 'every right' to keep her from uploading her characters, I simply asked. My side is explained in full in the previous post, as was the statement that I would work around this since she disagreed to it and didn't offer suggestions.
So here it is for Sublunary fans to have an opinion on as she wished, with both sides of the story. I'm not trying to invite drama, I'm trying to help her get a view from the fan perspective. As I already stated, I would work around her disagreement with my suggestion so as far as I'm concerned this is pretty moot, but she wants opinions. As always, please be civil in the comments, this isn't a flame war nor should it be. Simply state your opinion for her and if need be, your reasons why.
